MLB: Giants Willing to Roll Dice With Chase in FA

John Fennelly , Lead Writer

Question: did anyone think the Giants were going to start the 2013 season with Chase Blackburn as the MLB?

If you answered ‘yes’, why, and if you answered ‘no’, you get an A for paying attention.

Blackburn is eligible for free agency next week after his reps and the Giants could not come to terms on a contract this winter.

“There is no understanding with the Giants,” Blackburn’s agent, Richard Katz, told Tom Rock of Newsday on yesterday. “It appears he’ll hit the open market on the 12th.”

OK, let him. The Giants can rebid for his services beginning Saturday. If no deal is struck, I’d miss him but let’s be frank: the Giants need to upgrade at that position. Blackburn, if brought back, would serve mainly as insurance at LB and help out on special teams.

The Giants brought in  - and stuck with – Mark Herzlich for two seasons while he righted himself through illness and injury. They are ready for the payoff. He will get first crack at MLB even if Blackburn returns.

Don’t forget, they also have Jake Muasau, who showed promise in training camp last season. He will 23 next month, the same age as many of the players coming out of this year’s draft. The difference between Muasau and any player the Giants draft this April is that Muasau has already been initiated into the NFL.

 

123 comments
dzruggie
dzruggie

A day late with this comment :-).   Went to the game last night and a few observations 1: Classy move by the Shark fateful as they recognized Nabby with some video stats and then showed Nabby in street clothes where they gave him a standing ovation.

2: No confidence.  The Sharks D stood them up at the red line until the third when the Isles started to gain moment and actually transition.

3: No D zone coverage and No breakout so no transition game

4: Clearly if you fix 2 and 3 the speed will give teams fits in transition. 

5: For much of the game there seemed to be an air of defeatism (sans JT's line and Poulin) that hung over them.  Hamonic was the worst offender as he had zero drive or fire until the 3rd.

Last my 1st time seeing JT live and he is just unbelievable.  It is awesome to see and hear the other teams fans all gasp when JT brings the puck into the zone.  It was a pleasure to watch.  

ibethr4u
ibethr4u

Last time an Islander goalie performed like that was Roloson against Toronto a few years back. Roloson was tremendous in stopping nearly 60 shots and Bailey getting the game winner. Unfortunately, we would need that type of performance nearly every night with the defense we roll out night after night.

chasct
chasct

Tavares was a monster n the ice last night..been waiting for the day when jack took of the reigns. JT and KO out there a lot and dominated play. MORE OF THIS !!! Frans and AMac were greatas well. deHaan getting better each game, Ness not a liability.

rmreturns
rmreturns

nice win last night. weathered the storm in the first( back to back man down, back to back games), scored two in the third to tie it( WAIT- somebody else blew a 2 goal third period lead), and won in the shootout( with the mandatory- are you kidding me moment as Poulin got dinged).


After the first period rope a dope, the isles were short handed 3 times, they played a pretty even game. Vanek even hit the post on our single man advantage( cue the one post a game, that doesn't go in when the game is in balance). 


de Haan with 26 minutes last night, continues to play well after 7 NHL starts. Carkner took a dumb penalty, then a misplay that left his man uncovered for a score. Just seeing to much ice time, for a guy with his ability.


With no word on VIZ, maybe Strait is nearly back. IF not- at some point, Donovan needs to come back up, and get the Carkner minutes. Donovan has got so much more upside then Carkner- get him back in there, mistakes and all.


Garth, please sign Vanek. Second of a back to back, on the road, with the Sharks having last change- the Isles top line was dangerous. In the last two nights, both the Ducks and Sharks knew what was coming, but those three still did damage. All three are a threat when they carry the puck.  Change nothing but the contract status of Vanek. Lotsa points coming from that trio...

isles23
isles23

Just to give some perspective about the complainers here. People on Detroit blogs complain about ther team, especially ther D. Now isles fans certainly have had reason to complain more than Detroit fans but it just shows no matter what some people will always complain, even after their team wins a game. So if your not one of those people just enjoy the win and hope for the best for this team moving forward. LETS GO ISLANDERS!!!

Donald Yacona
Donald Yacona

Naturally I missed it. I saw a tweet that Poulin might have hurt himself, any word on that?

Ari BZ
Ari BZ

Offseason moves that need to be made:


Sign Vanek longterm!! Do whatever it takes!! Players like him don't grow on trees, I don't care about the couple of draft picks Snow could flip him for!


Extend Poulin and let him become, or at least attempt to become, the starter of the team 


Sign a guy like Jonas Gustavsson to backup/spell/rotate with Poulin. He is playing lights out this year, is a young veteran, and can take over during a slump by Poulin.


Sign a steady veteran (the younger the better) defenseman. Not quite sure, but don't think the D market is great (at least for defensemen under 30).


Cut loose: Bouchard, Regin, Nabokov (I love the guy, but it's time), MacDonald, Martinek. 


Promote: Lee and Donovan (and keep de Haan up as well).


Vanek-Tavares-Okposo

Grabner-Strome-Bailey

Lee-Nielsen-Nelson

Martin-Cizikas-Clutterbuck


Extras: McDonald


Hamonic-de Haan

Visnovsky-Donovan

Reinhart-UFA Vet


Extras: Hickey, Strait, Carkner (buyout?)


Poulin

Gustavsson



since72
since72

I must say, I really miss the down vote button for some of these guys.  The comments are always the same negativity. 

We're all frustrated by this season, but come on, we won a road game against a good team after being down 2 in the 3rd!  A little bit of joy would not be out of place.  

Serious fans who post here should consider not responding the the guys who offer nothing but the same complaints every day. 

Joey Ferguson
Joey Ferguson

can anyone explain that stupid penalty carkner took..... he doesnt belong on this team. bad penalties night in and night out.... and he usually only shows his toughness against weaker players....

delo
delo

Wish I could have stayed up and watched the rest of this one. Happy for the win, hope its the start of a trend.....

isles23
isles23

We won yesterday, if we win tomorrow that's two in a row, if we win the next game that's called a winning streak. It has happened before.

TomDinNJ
TomDinNJ

A much needed win. I thought the Sharks looked really good, but I guess on any given night anything can happen. I thought Tavares gave it his all and kind of willed the team on. I believe we have some good pieces to this puzzle, but the good pieces have to compensate every night for the bad pieces. Grabner, Neilson & Bailey.....something has to give here. I like Grabner for his speed and would keep him. Perhaps its time to move Franz and Bailey is an enigma. He is a passenger and night in and night out I don't like his effort. He cant stay on the second line. he is more 4th line right now or try to move him out of here. Obviously we need help on D. I like what I see so far from deHaan. We need a bruiser or two with some talent and need to move on a couple smurfs and softies. Regin is in that mold clearly, he's no help to us. Problem here remains, owner wont spend and GM is a bit slow behind the wheel. I'm split on Cappy, more down on Snow for not doing his job and the owner who I have no clue what he is thinking.

camb33
camb33

WE WANT THE CUP!!!!...WE WANT THE CUP!!!!!

ohiofan
ohiofan

Finally. Now with Strome coming there is hope another line besides the 1st will actually score a goal at some point.

dzruggie
dzruggie

@ibethr4u Seeing it live it is not just the defense, it is the entire defensive system - coverage by all parties.  

ibethr4u
ibethr4u

@chasct

Unfortunately while your impression of JT and the first line is accurate, but it should be noted that He and the rest of his line was so noticeable out there was because of the amount of shifts they were getting. It seemed to me that Cappy was roling Jt's line every othershift in the third period. As much of a beast the first line performed last night, was the polar opposite of the 2nd and third line. Although I liked Brock Nelson and Grabner very much last night. Most of the first was a scramble in the Isles zone and much of it right in front of the goalie. You're NOT going to survive many games like that.

dzruggie
dzruggie

@rmreturns Spot on but I assume you are being tongue and cheek about the rope a dope.  The Sles could not make a pass or cover in their zone.  The dope was the 3 horrific penalties - 2 by Hamonic (careless delay of game and a very weak play with the puck and he then hooked the guy).  The first was Poulin and him alone.  


You are right about Vanek he needs to be signed.

rmreturns
rmreturns

@isles23 hey, some guys are just trolls. engage them when your looking to torment the stupid, other wise ignore them. 

    Some guys are just negative because its their nature,  they can't deal with adversity, or they are worn down( which makes little sense- as if being a fan is taxing).

Zee Executioner
Zee Executioner

@isles23 okay, johnny come lately. winning one game out of the last 11, effectively tanking the season, is supposed to make a fan of any team excited?


Ridiculous delusional prattle.  

isles23
isles23

He's OK, he extended his left leg to make the save on the first shot in the SO. Looked bad at first but it became pretty obvious is was just a cramp. Trainer came out and Poulin was just killing liquids and stayed in to finish the shootout

ivo leggi
ivo leggi

@Ari BZ   Vanek situation scares me a little. I feel he won't be around next year! Come trade deadline we will know!

ivo leggi
ivo leggi

@Ari BZ Yeah.....u need to start cutting the dead weight! Snow is very slow to do that!

shop for ufa d and goalie this summer

I wonder what Bailey would fetch for trade scenario.

Derek Scheer
Derek Scheer

@Ari BZ The first move they make should be signing UFA Deryk Engelland , he is a tough hard nosed team player that this team desperately needs. Enough with 2 players who are kind of tough and another 18 trying to win the Lady Bing.

ibethr4u
ibethr4u

@since72

Have to agree there. really miss the old way to comment. Too hard to get through all this nonsense. No down vote stinks too.

Zee Executioner
Zee Executioner

@since72 maybe the same complaints wouldn't be offered everyday if this team wasn't being used by it's owner like his own personal barf bag. 

slapshot18_rs
slapshot18_rs

@since72 agree, but sometimes its hard not to.  every team has bad fans obviously, but gets frustrating to read about nonstop.  

rmreturns
rmreturns

@Joey Ferguson Burns landed a clean, solid check on Frans. Elbows down, skates on ice. Frans had just moved the puck up from the corner left side our the Isles cage.

Carkner decided he didn't like it, so he went after..... Hertl...


Because Carkner is frustrated, and it was a stupid move. If your gonna stand up, then stand up to Burns...  DUMB, 100% DUMB... Carkner made up for it by uncovering Pavelski,  resulting in the Sharks second goal..

shlo
shlo

Lack of brain power, did not take his vitamins , needs to find a better way to relieve his frustrations maybe? is he married?

puckdad99
puckdad99

Yes, he wasn't just good, he was SPECTACULAR!

dzruggie
dzruggie

@ibethr4u Grabner played well, he was flying and actually 1 shift he was caught on the ice with JT and Vanek and had scoring chances.  Frans has become completely invisible.  Looked like he is setting up the 2nd line to be Bailey, Strome and either Grabs or Nelson and the other line Frans, Cal and Grabs or Nelson

isles23
isles23

I've been here the hole time zee, incase you didn't notice the comment section changed so I changed my name too. I'm not saying you have to think this team is gonna go on a super run and be amazing. I'm simply pointing out a fact of life. Go to the sharks blogs right now. Some there are wondering if their team will ever win again. They have 43 points and people are saying that! And btw the season isn't over. Thanks to being in the worst division in hockey isles are 9 points out of a playoff spot. With the run they have been on that number should be 20.

Don22
Don22

Sorry Zee, but your refusal to accept people that choose to try to find positives on a FAN website is ridiculous delusional prattle.

dzruggie
dzruggie

@rmreturns @Ari BZ It was a great win - I don;t want to go crazy but it could be a season turning win.  All of a sudden in the third they were the Islanders again.  After they tied it is was high adrenaline 

Ari BZ
Ari BZ

@Derek Scheer @Ari BZ He would certainly fill the need of the UFA vet on D this team needs. I'd be happy to have him.

Ari BZ
Ari BZ

@Lyle Gillen Care to specify why or not? What about the moves I asked for is not good? Vanek, an elite winger? Signing Gustavvson, who is tearing it up? Promoting Lee, Strome, Donovan (all tearing it up in the AHL?, Bringing aboard Reinhart, an A level prospect? Signing a veteran UFA defenseman? Please do enlighten me. Hmm...guess not.

Don22
Don22

The write to him.  Go picket outside his office.  I can look up the address for you if you want.  Don't watch games.  Do go to games.  You aren't allowed to incessantly complain about something if you aren't willing to do something about it.  Go be heard.  Join the masses.  But stop dishing it on a fan website.  Create your own website.  Maybe www.ihatewang.com is available.


Don22
Don22

I agree RS.  I find myself getting sucked into it and I know it's not like they are going to all of the sudden go....Hey, you know?  You guys are right.

I just hate all the negative. 

dzruggie
dzruggie

@isles23 Funny at the game the Shark fans were actually screaming you can't be seriously loosing - it the Islanders for X sake lol - but they do respect JT that is for sure.

Don22
Don22

Clearly....troll.

Zee Executioner
Zee Executioner

@Don22 Yeah, you would, as you have some connection to Chuckie the Wang, CLEARLY.